Monday, January 12, 2015

No #JusticeForEthan - Two Years Later

Two years ago, tonight, three off-duty deputies moonlighting as mall security killed Ethan Saylor.

  • They killed Ethan Saylor by forcing him to the ground, fracturing his trachea.
  • They killed him because they couldn't figure out how to deal with a large, cursing, man with Down syndrome.
  • They killed him because no one in the theater, some of whom recognized that Ethan had Down syndrome, volunteered to buy him a ticket.
  • They killed him because he didn't fit their idea of people with Down syndrome as cute little kids and they didn't know what to do with a man, cursing at them, not complying.
  • They killed him because they couldn't wait for his mother to arrive, although she was on the way, and Ethan's aide told them this. But non-compliance, for many officers, requires the use of force. So they used force, and he died.
These last two issues - representations of Down syndrome as cute/children (usually white) and the necessity felt by many law enforcement officers to respond to non-compliance with force - have been pretty much the central themes of my writing for most of the last two years. I think about Ethan Saylor and his family a lot, but especially today.

I have three published pieces on him.

His experience stays with me throughout my writing on police violence and disability, though, often on my mind. One of so many victims, but the victim that made it clear to me that perhaps I could help reframe the problem not as one of bad cops, and not as one of requiring special treatment, but of fundamental human rights and fundamental shifts to the way police respond to non-compliant but non-threatening situations.



I'm sorry I never got to meet Ethan. I'm sorry that while there's been a lot of progress since his death and good outcome have emerged, none of those outcomes include holding the deputies or their supervisor

5 comments:

The Illinois Model said...

His story is being shared among police officers in a relatively large police Use of Force program being pioneered in Indiana. The program began in December 2014, and will continue with much momentum into summer 2015.

Thoughts are being shifted....

David Perry said...

Do you have a contact for that UoF program?

The Illinois Model said...

It's being moderated by The Virtus Group, Inc. (Chicago & Calgary) and Reimer & Karlson, LLC attorneys out of Illinois.

David Perry said...

Oh well, then, I know just who to talk to.

rob j said...

I can give another example that fits this bill. Adult male living in a privately run group home licensed by the state starts aggressively insisting on going outside (at 11:00 pm, in his pajamas on a night that the temps were under 20 deg F) protocol was to call the police, believing that this individual would respond to a male authority figure. The officer entered the building, pulled out a taser and shot the man, prior to saying a single word.
This is neither providing "reasonable accommodation" nor regarding the "purpotraitor" as a human being capable of any degre of reasoning.